Medicare Supplement in Jefferson County, Florida. About 4,104 Medicare beneficiaries live here, with roughly 62 percent in Medicare Advantage plans. Top carriers include Capital Health Plan and UnitedHealthcare/AARP. For free help comparing plans, call Mr. and Mrs. Insurance, a licensed Florida agency, or visit mrandmrsinsurance.com.
Jefferson County Medicare Supplement — quick answer
Jefferson County, FL has 4,104 Medicare beneficiaries per CMS Q1 2024 data, with about 62% enrolled in Medicare Advantage. The top medicare supplement carriers are Capital Health Plan, UnitedHealthcare/AARP, Humana. We compare these plans for free and never charge a fee.
Prefer to listen?
Free audio version, generated on demand by Azure Speech.
The Jefferson County medicare supplement market
Jefferson County posts one of the highest Medicare Advantage adoption rates in Florida — roughly 62% of its 4,104 beneficiaries chose an MA plan over Original Medicare. That level of uptake usually means carriers compete hard locally, so the extra benefits (dental, OTC allowance, transportation, gym) tend to be richer than the Florida average. The county skews older than the Florida average (25% are 65 or older), which means heavy carrier competition and meaningful plan turnover each Annual Enrollment Period — a yearly review almost always pays off. Capital Health Plan currently leads the county by enrollment, but the lowest total-cost plan for your specific drugs and doctors is often a smaller carrier — which is why we run all of them side by side instead of pushing the biggest name.
Jefferson County at a glance
Population (2024 ACS)
15,091
Medicare beneficiaries
4,104
MA penetration
62%
Age 65 or older
25%
What makes Jefferson County different: Jefferson County has no hospital within its borders and is a designated primary-care Health Professional Shortage Area, so its roughly 4,100 Medicare beneficiaries travel about 30 minutes west to Tallahassee (Leon County) for hospital care; about 17% of them (711) are dual-eligible for Medicaid, and the Tallahassee-based nonprofit Capital Health Plan HMO is the county's single largest Medicare Advantage plan.
Top Medicare Advantage plans in Jefferson County
Capital Health Plan (HMO)
4.5-star CMS rating
UnitedHealthcare/AARP
4.5-star CMS rating
Humana
4.5-star CMS rating
Source: CMS Monthly MA Enrollment by State/County/Contract (latest Q1 2024). Enrollment figures refresh monthly at data.cms.gov.
Before you enroll: verify your hospital + doctor in Jefferson County
Each Medicare Supplement plan builds its own provider network — a hospital that's in-network
on one plan may be out-of-network on another. Jefferson County has 2
major hospital systems. Before you enroll, check that your preferred hospital and physicians
participate in the specific plan you're considering.
Major hospitals to verify
▸Tallahassee Memorial HealthCare (Tallahassee, Leon County)
▸HCA Florida Capital Hospital / Capital Regional Medical Center (Tallahassee, Leon County)
Call each hospital's billing office directly — or use the carrier's
network tool on the right to search by hospital name.
Top Jefferson carriers — network lookup
Capital Health Plan 4.5★
Search "Capital Health provider directory" or call the carrier directly.
Free help in Jefferson County: Florida SHINE — Jefferson — call 1-800-963-5337.
SHIP counselors offer free unbiased Medicare guidance and can run network checks at no cost.
Or skip the cross-checking — we run network checks against your prescriptions and doctors
at no cost during any consult.
Medicare AEP opens in 132 days
132 daysuntil open
Outside the windows, Special Enrollment Periods (SEP) still let you change plans if you moved, lost coverage, qualify for Extra Help / dual eligible, or had a plan terminated. Call to see if you qualify.
Pick a time on Matt or Robin's calendar — 15 minutes, no sales pressure, no obligation. We'll walk through the Jefferson County plans that fit your situation.
Major hospitals: Tallahassee Memorial HealthCare (Tallahassee, Leon County), HCA Florida Capital Hospital / Capital Regional Medical Center (Tallahassee, Leon County)
Frequently Asked Questions
How many Medicare beneficiaries live in Jefferson County?▾
About 4,104 Floridians in Jefferson County are enrolled in Medicare as of 2024 CMS data. About 62% are in Medicare Advantage plans; the rest are in Original Medicare (with or without Medigap).
Who are the top Medicare carriers in Jefferson County?▾
The largest carriers in Jefferson County are Capital Health Plan (HMO), UnitedHealthcare/AARP, Humana. We work with all of them and a few smaller carriers that often have better rates for specific situations.
What SHIP resources are available in Jefferson County?▾
Florida SHINE — Jefferson (1-800-963-5337) provides free unbiased Medicare counseling. Major hospitals in the county include Tallahassee Memorial HealthCare (Tallahassee, Leon County), HCA Florida Capital Hospital / Capital Regional Medical Center (Tallahassee, Leon County).
Hey 👋 — I'm trained on every page of mrandmrsinsurance.com. Ask me anything
about Medicare, ACA, or life insurance and I'll cite the exact source. For specific quotes or applications, I'll send you to Matt or Robin.
Try one of these
Educational only — not medical or legal advice. We do not offer every plan in your area. Call 1-800-MEDICARE for all options.
